Once the minor league season comes to an end we get into my favorite time of year, the offseason. There are a couple of reasons that I love the months of November and December for Bowman with the main one being that it is the best time for us to be buying singles while the market is down. If there’s a player you really like as a breakout pick for 2027 there is no better time than now to be buying your stash as prices should be nearing the bottom before they begin to trend back up in the early part of next year.

Not only is it time to buy but it’s time for me to adjust. While the season is ongoing I do make very slight changes to how prospects are ranked but with there not being any breaks in the action I never really have an opportunity to take a deep dive into the formula to figure out what needs to be tweaked. The goal has always been to bring you prospect rankings that are the most accurate for predicting hobby success so when players have autograph prices that are way off from their rankings I make note of that so that I can circle back in November when I’m reworking all of the weights that go into my rankings.

One thing I really wanted to focus on this fall was messing around with how much a prospect’s team and position affected their value. Two players who jumped out at me as overperforming in the market compared to the hobby rankings were Franklin Arias and Dax Kilby. My rankings already have weights in place for position where defensive homes like catcher that the hobby has deemed unsexy are penalized while shortstops are given a boost. This works for teams as well. Since you can be a great Marlins hitting prospect without getting the same sort of market reaction as if you’re even a halfway decent Mets prospects one of those loses you points where the other moves you up. Arias and Kilby play both a premium defensive position AND do so for an elite hobby franchise causing their cards to go up much faster when they play well compared to other prospects. That sort of double bonus is just one example of additional points I’ve added to the formula in an attempt to reflect the card market more accurately with my rankings.

Over the past couple of days I’ve been putting updated base autograph prices via ProspectPulse into my hitter rankings and sorting the buy ratings by teams and positions, applying bonuses and deductions for both until each looked well balanced in buys/sells. The beautiful thing about ranking prospects specifically for Bowman is that things are always changing. People will say “catchers don’t sell” until a Rainiel Rodriguez comes along and then suddenly they do. That’s why it’s very important for me to stay on top of these adjustments. After combing through about six months worth of price changes from March to September to see what really contributes to Bowman prices, I’ve made some tweaks and am comfortable saying that these are the best set of hobby hitter rankings that I’ve ever put out. Along with these changes I have also added in 2026 draftees for the first time to the hobby rankings (highlighted in purple) because it’s never too early to start circling some names you like for 2026 Bowman Draft.

For those of you who have never been subscribed during an offseason we’re about to get into the articles that help us make the most money each season and those are the Team Buy Sheets. Typically in January I will start my deep dive into all 30 MLB franchises and give you a detailed breakdown of which prospects, both hitters and pitchers, I believe have the best growth potential for the following season. In an attempt to get you all of that information while prices are at their lowest I am going to start those in November this time around and I’m working on the first few teams already. Not a ton should change between now and then in the rankings department so the buy ratings in today’s article will give you a pretty good idea of which players I’ll be stamping as a ‘buy’ when those team sheets start to roll out. Normally there will be an even split between players who are undervalued versus overvalued during the season but in the spirit of buying for next year I’ve reset all of the expected values to what we typically see in March and since prices are down right now there’s quite a bit more green than usual.

Buy Ratings

5.0 - Strongest Buy (Target price is 100%+ higher than current price)

4.5-4.9 - Strong Buy

4.0-4.4 - Buy

3.5-3.9 - Lean Buy

3.1-3.4 - Slightly Undervalued

3.0 - Spot on

2.5-2.9 - Slightly Overvalued

2.1-2.4 - Overvalued

2.0 - Very Overvalued

logo

Subscribe to Premium to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Already a subscriber? Sign in

A subscription gets you:

  • 1st Bowman Autograph prices with Buy Ratings
  • Bowman Prospect Rankings updated weekly
  • Daily stats & leaderboards for MLB prospects
  • Weekly prospect "Hot Sheets"
  • In-depth analysis on new Bowman products
  • Subscriber-only posts and full archive

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right