If you haven’t checked out yesterday’s article make sure you do so as I went into detail about what changes I’ve made for the 2027 season when it comes to ranking hitting prospects. Today I’m doing the same but for our pitchers. Looking at the same pricing data over the past six months one thing that stood out to me is that pitchers seem to be a bit more team-proof than hitters. There were a few franchises that I had to penalize on the hitters side for their prospects selling way below my expectations but then pitchers for the same team didn’t suffer the same fate. That led to a shuffling around of the team weights for our pitching list.
Our most notable change however will come in the way that strikeouts are counted towards a player’s score. Yesterday I mentioned that guys who played shortstop for elite hobby franchises needed a double bonus because of the way the market overreacts in a way to their cards. No stat on the sheet does the same for pitchers quite like strikeouts. In fact when I looked at my old rankings versus today’s prices the two biggest discrepancies that I found for “overvalued” players both had a K/9 (strikeouts per 9 innings) in the top 2% of all pitching prospects. Just like Bowman people love hitters with power, they love pitchers who rack up strikeouts. To account for that there has been an additional bonus to those who generate the most whiffs as well as small deductions for those who don’t miss many bats. Going forward I think this will help the pitcher rankings be even more indicative of the card market than they already were.
As I did with the hitters I’m also adding all 2026 draftees to the pitcher rankings for the first time so that we can get a jump on our 2026 Bowman Draft research. Those players will be highlighted in purple. Again remember that the expected values aren’t for today they have been reset to where we’d normally see them come March, so while there is a lot more green than we’ve seen in the past few months that’s by design since now is the best time to buy before prices go back up come baseball season.
Buy Ratings
5.0 - Strongest Buy (Target price is 100%+ higher than current price)
4.5-4.9 - Strong Buy
4.0-4.4 - Buy
3.5-3.9 - Lean Buy
3.1-3.4 - Slightly Undervalued
3.0 - Spot on
2.5-2.9 - Slightly Overvalued
2.1-2.4 - Overvalued
2.0 - Very Overvalued
Subscribe to Premium to read the rest.
Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.
UpgradeAlready a subscriber? Sign in
A subscription gets you:
- 1st Bowman Autograph prices with Buy Ratings
- Bowman Prospect Rankings updated weekly
- Daily stats & leaderboards for MLB prospects
- Weekly prospect "Hot Sheets"
- In-depth analysis on new Bowman products
- Subscriber-only posts and full archive